guide

A no-closing-cost refinance still needs a cost comparison

Lender credits and financed fees can reduce the cash you bring to closing. Compare the rate, new balance and payment before choosing either.

Original illustration of a closing cost document

Original RefinanceNews editorial illustration

When a refinance advertisement says “no closing costs,” ask how the charges are covered. A lender credit may offset charges in exchange for a higher rate. Alternatively, fees may be added to the new balance. Those arrangements produce different payments and different debts.

Freddie Mac’s refinancing FAQ flags both possibilities. The useful comparison starts with written loan terms and the amount you will owe after closing.

Compare the same loan with and without a credit

Ask the lender to price both versions at the same time, using the same balance, term, product and lock period. The CFPB explains how rate-linked lender credits exchange lower upfront costs for a higher interest rate. Some credits serve other purposes, so have the lender explain the specific credit on your offer.

Here is an invented comparison for two fully amortizing, 30-year fixed loans. These rates are assumptions, not current offers.

Assumption Pay the assumed charges in cash Receive an assumed lender credit
Loan amount $300,000 $300,000
Annual interest rate 6.25% 6.50%
Cash-paid charges used for this comparison $6,000 $0
Monthly principal and interest $1,847.15 $1,896.20

The credit version preserves $6,000 at closing and requires about $49.05 more each month. Dividing $6,000 by $49.05 gives roughly 122.3 months. The accumulated payment difference passes $6,000 during month 123.

That rough crossover leaves out the different balances remaining when either loan is paid off, the value of keeping the cash, and any other charges. It also assumes the entire $6,000 difference is covered by the credit. Ask which costs and deposits remain payable separately.

Financed fees change the balance instead

Now keep the 6.25% rate but add $6,000 in fees to the loan. The new balance becomes $306,000. Over 30 years, principal and interest would be approximately $1,884.09 a month, about $36.94 more than the $300,000 version at that rate.

You would owe the extra $6,000 as principal and pay interest on the amount still outstanding. Adding fees to the balance can make closing easier to fund, but it creates a larger loan.

Check cash to close separately

Loan charges, prepaid expenses and escrow deposits do different jobs. A credit that offsets lender charges may leave other cash requirements. Review the closing-cost and cash-to-close sections using the CFPB Loan Estimate explainer, then ask for a line-by-line explanation of the amount due.

For your own comparison, use our mortgage payment calculator to test each proposed balance and rate. The refinance break-even calculator compares cash-paid costs with a monthly payment reduction; it does not compare the overall cost of two competing refinance offers.

For general information. Consider the terms of your own loan and your financial circumstances.

Report an error or request a correction ↗

Keep reading

Privacy choices