guide

Fixed mortgage rate, higher payment: what to check first

A payment increase can come from taxes, insurance or an escrow shortage. Here is how to find the change in your own statement.

Original illustration of a row of homes

Original RefinanceNews editorial illustration

Your mortgage rate can stay fixed while the amount leaving your checking account rises. The first place to look is the payment breakdown: principal and interest, escrow, mortgage insurance and any added charges.

On a fully amortizing fixed-rate mortgage with regular scheduled payments, principal and interest ordinarily stay level. Taxes and homeowners insurance have their own bills. If your servicer collects money for them through escrow, changes in those bills can reach your monthly payment. Fannie Mae explains these common causes.

Put the old statement beside the new one

Find the first line that changed. If principal and interest are identical but escrow rose, a new mortgage rate will not explain the increase. Open the escrow analysis that accompanied the notice and compare its tax and insurance figures with the actual bills.

An escrow shortage can add another amount on top of the higher ongoing expense. The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency explains that a bank may collect a shortage through increased payments and may offer repayment options. Ask your servicer which options apply to your account.

How a $100 increase can become $150

Consider this invented household budget. It illustrates the arithmetic, rather than a lender’s quote or a required repayment schedule.

Monthly component Before After
Principal and interest $1,800 $1,800
Property taxes collected through escrow $400 $475
Homeowners insurance collected through escrow $125 $150
Temporary shortage repayment $0 $50
Total $2,325 $2,475

Taxes and insurance add $100 a month. Repaying an assumed $600 shortage over 12 months adds $50. The total increase is $150 even though principal and interest have not moved.

In that example, paying the $600 shortage separately would address the temporary $50 component if the servicer permits it. The extra $100 for the underlying bills would remain. Have the servicer confirm the revised payment before sending a lump sum.

Ask for the numbers behind the notice

Keep the conversation specific: “Which tax bill and insurance premium did you use? How much of the increase is a shortage repayment? When does that repayment end?”

If the escrow figures match the bills, questions about a tax assessment belong with the taxing authority. Questions about an insurance renewal belong with the insurer. Refinancing alone does not reduce those bills.

If principal and interest changed, check the loan documents and any temporary payment arrangement. The CFPB lists other possible causes, including an adjustable rate, an ending temporary buydown, changing mortgage insurance, fees or a servicing error. For a suspected mistake, keep the notice, statements and call notes; the same CFPB page explains written information requests and notices of error.

To rebuild your housing budget, enter annual taxes and insurance separately in our mortgage payment calculator. Use the amounts from your own bills, then account for any temporary shortage payment separately.

For general information. Consider the terms of your own loan and your financial circumstances.

Report an error or request a correction ↗

Keep reading

Privacy choices